Biodiversity of tropical reef fishes

University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa
Brian Bowen, (808) 236-7426
Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology
Tara Hicks, (808) 956-3151
School of Ocean & Earth Science & Technology
Posted: Apr 12, 2005

Honolulu, Hawaii - Dealing a new blow to the dominant evolutionary paradigm, Luiz Rocha and colleagues from the Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute, Harvard University, the University of Florida and the University of Hawaii, report coral reef fish from neighboring habitats may differ more from one another than from fish thousands of miles away. An ecological speciation model for coral reef organisms may spur the development of a more synthetic treatment of speciation on land and sea.

Coral reefs, like tropical forests, express an extreme of life's capacity for variation. Yet high biodiversity in tropical seas foil evolutionists' attempts to explain the splitting of one species into two on the basis of geographical barriers. According to standard evolutionary theory proposed by Dobzhansky and Mayr more than 50 years ago, mountain building, island formation, glaciation and other processes isolate populations within a species. Over evolutionary time, these populations mutate independently until individuals from distinct populations can no longer interbreed and become new species.

"Most species are believed to arise in isolation, but there are few opportunities for such isolation in the continuous aquatic medium of the ocean," explains Brian Bowen, an assistant researcher at the Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology on Coconut Island. "Further it was believed that extensive dispersal by larvae would prevent specialization in adjacent ecosystems. Hence the known rules of evolution seemed to contradict the high biodiversity in tropical seas!"

What explains the evolution of a huge number of closely related fish species on reefs in an open undersea world where currents constantly stir the waters, washing in fish or their larvae from afar, a world without well-defined geographical barriers? Rocha et al. took a close look at the genetics of one group of Western Atlantic tropical reef fishes (wrasses, genus Halichoeres) throughout their range and were surprised by what they found.

Rocha explains: "I was interested in the Amazon barrier. The Amazon and Orinoco's freshwater and sediment discharge off of northeastern South America is so immense that it precludes coral reef formation from the mouth of the Amazon North to Trinidad and Tabago. This 2000 km gap is believed to be a strong barrier for corals and associated reef organisms."

"My idea was to test whether or not wrasses in the genus Halichoeres were genetically different North and South of this barrier. Since all of these species have similar abilities to disperse, I expected to find genetic differences that corresponded to the barrier in all of them, but, surprisingly, that wasn't the case."

Mitochondrial DNA of adult fish and larvae from three locations in the Caribbean and from three locations in Brazil showed much clearer genetic differences within, rather than across, the two sides of the Amazon barrier. Genetically similar fish were found in ecologically similar habitats--even thousands of miles apart.

Wrasses collected only 360 km apart along the Brazilian coast were genetically more distinct than were fish collected 4200 km apart, from Fernando de Noronha island off of the Brazilian coast and St. Croix in the Caribbean.

The fact that evolutionary partitions correspond more closely to habitat type, rather than to conventional geographical barriers, indicates that local speciation events may overcome the homogenizing effect of migration in the ocean, vindicating Darwin's original ideas about the importance of ecological speciation in biodiversity evolution.

"In this report, we demonstrate speciation in adjacent ecosystems without the isolation that is supposed to be necessary," says Bowen. "This "ecological" speciation can explain why the Indo-Pacific has enormous biodiversity without having barriers."

Research article citation:

Ecological speciation in tropical reef fishes. Proceedings of the Royal Society B. Vol. 272 #1563

Hawaii Media contact:

Tara Hicks, Outreach Specialist, School of Ocean and Earth Science and Technology, University of Hawaii
(808) 956-3151,

Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute (STRI) Media contact:

Contact: Beth King,, 202-786-2094 x8216

Images and Video available at


School of Ocean and Earth Science and Technology

SOEST in the News

The Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute (STRI), with headquarters in Panama City, Panama, is one of the world's leading centers for basic research on the ecology, behavior and evolution of tropical organisms.

For more information, visit: